Back to archive

article · Publishing and Media

Article Review: The Church Response to Sexual Abuse Matters

Sign in to access

This resource is available to repository members and above.

Article Review: The Church Response to Sexual Abuse Matters It is in the church’s power to act. I believe it’s time to launch a different conversation around the #metoo #churchtoo movement. While exposing the predators and giving survivors a voice is critically important, the church needs to be challenged in its response to survivors as more pastors are exposed. There’s a growing, immediate need for sensitivity from the church who, by its intrinsic nature, should defend the weakest among us. As more survivors come forward, the church must decide how it will respond to and interact with those who disclose? We are, after all, required “...not to withhold good from those to whom it is due, when it is in your power to act” (New International Version, Prov. 3:27). Good, in situations like this, comforts and defends the weakest among us first. It presents a no tolerance front concerning injustice, and while forgiveness is important, it understands the critical importance of supporting the broken. Good does not applaud mega church pastors like Andy Savage for asking for forgiveness for sexually abusing a 17-year-old teenager, Jules Woodson, while serving as her youth pastor twenty years ago. This, as a survivor of sexual assault might see it, is the least a perpetrator can do after committing such a crime. Savage’s confession was not noble. It was necessary considering the Christian faith. Savage isn’t courageous for admitting his crime. Woodson is courageous. Savage’s loss of status was not horrendous. But Woodson’s 20-year-torment resulting from Savage’s crime against her is. Until the church comes to grip with these truths, good will continue to be withheld by individuals and churches who have the power to act but fail to do so. Congregations must stand against the predatorial behavior of pastors like Savage. In one of the most infamous church sexual abuse cases, Archbishop Earl Paulk, escaped prosecution and discipline for decades for incest and sexually assaulting numerous women within his mega church. The church was noted as participating in a massive coverups. I also have a #metoo #churchtoo story I spent most of my childhood moving through the foster care system following heinous physical, emotional and sexual abuse from multiple abusers. I turned to the church in efforts to gain healing from my lifelong torment only to have my vulnerability exploited again as I fell prey to sexual abuse at the hand of a pastor I called daddy. It has taken years of therapy to recover from these experiences, gain some sense of inner peace and to grow in my faith without questioning God. I am convinced, however, that this might not have happened if the other church leaders I trusted had failed to act on my behalf or stand with me through my disclosure and recovery process. Unfortunately, the church response I received is extremely rare. The lives of Woodson and countless others coming forward in the wake of the #metoo #churchtoo stand might have been considerably different if the church had chosen not to withhold good from them and used its power to act. The first response Clearly, the church plays a significant role in supporting survivors and families following disclosures of sexual abuse at the hands of clergy. I am convinced that the “first response” to disclosure set the stage for (1) empowering survivors to speak; (2) creating a safe environment to heal; and (3) creating an atmosphere committed to educating its communities about all aspects of sexual abuse. The plea to believe the victim of a sexual assault is a compassionate cry to meet that person in their most humiliating and vulnerable moment with extreme compassion. It is about creating an atmosphere of safety and trust that will enable the survivor to receive much needed help, counsel and move through the healing process. It is also about identifying predators and making every effort within one’s power to ensure that they are unable to harm anyone else. Just like paramedics responding to a street shooting, the first order of business is to treat the injured by employing any medical procedure necessary to save their lives and ease the pain and suffering. Just because a sexual assault survivor does not exhibit outward signs of trauma or leave visible blood trails in the dirt or on the pavement, does not mean he or she is not in a life or death situation. Even if there are doubts concerning the validity of a sexual assault allegation, there is still the eternal call to kindness and compassion. There remains the power to act as if the disclosure is true for the sake of protecting the most vulnerable among us. Yes, Savage admitted to sexually abusing Woodson. As a community of believers, however, we must recognize that he is not the person who needs the greatest amount of comfort and support right now. This perpetrator should not be the center of the church’s attention and compassion! Rather, the cry should be Woodson and everyone she represents through an unbelievable courage to come forward. Questions in the #churchtoo conversation should be centered here: How can we ensure that our congregations are safe from clergy sexual abuse? What we do immediately to help survivors when disclosure occurs? Until the church responds to these properly, the stigma and mistreatment of those who have been sexually abused will continue to perpetuate a culture that shields the perpetrator and shames the victim. Bibliography Niebuhr, Gustav. “AN INSTANCE OF WOLVES IN SHEPHERDS' CLOTHING?” The Washington Post, February 3, 1993. Accessed February 5, 2018. https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/politics/1993/02/03/an-instance-of-wolves-in-shepherds-clothing/89d7499c-7bfc-4f69-bb66-94d7777e9993/?utm_term=.6605ec489e36.